Skip to main content

One Diagnosis, Many Realities: Meeting the needs of today’s lung cancer patients

SciencePersonalised healthcareOncologyLung cancer
A woman and an older man smile together, showcasing a warm and friendly relationship.

Vince Gaillard, Global Group Medical Director at Roche, reflects on the unique needs of people living with lung cancer and what can be done to meet these needs.

Potrait of Vincent

Around half of lung cancer patients are diagnosed at 70 or older,¹ and many aren’t just elderly - they’re frail, with compromised organ function.² Given these complexities, this population challenges oncology treatment as we know it and pushes us to rethink treatment decisions.

Vince Gaillard

Global Group Medical Director at Roche

Why does age and frailty matter when it comes to lung cancer care?

With age and frailty comes added treatment complexity.

Managing lung cancer is already complex, however treating frail and elderly patients requires even more careful decision making, taking into account many additional aspects. 

“It’s not only about identifying the best treatment for a person’s tumour presentation, it’s also essential to factor in co-existing medical conditions, vital organ function, cognitive status and social circumstances,” explains Vince. “A frail patient might struggle with standard treatments. Ultimately, it’s about weighing all these elements up and striking the perfect balance to support an individual’s overall wellbeing.”

How can we effectively identify frail patients?

Practical, standard guidelines are key.

There are acknowledged benchmark metrics to define ‘frailty’. These commonly include an ECOG performance status score of 2 or more and presenting with major comorbidities.3 While tools like the Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment (CGA) are considered the gold standard, their application isn’t yet standardised across clinical practice.4 “We need to recognise patients who are frail, yet eligible for treatment,” says Vince. “Working with clinicians to roll out a practical way to identify frail patients, and embed this into routine care – across regions and clinics - can support the creation of tailored care plans.”

On an individual basis, sometimes it's as simple as asking: is this patient a suitable candidate for standard
chemotherapy-based treatment? If not, what alternatives might better serve their needs?”

A woman and a nurse are holding hands, symbolizing support and care in a healthcare setting.
What do we mean by tailored care plans?

Between 40 and 70% of lung cancer patients live with other illnesses and disorders, such as COPD or high blood pressure.5 This affects their diagnosis, treatment and prognosis. Each additional underlying condition influences the treatment options available and increases the risk of interactions between the medicines they are already taking, along with any additional lung cancer treatments. “These patients often have reduced physiological reserve, making the balance between treating the cancer and preserving overall health even more critical," says Vince.

How can we deliver patient-focused care?

Shared decision making is essential.

Survival. Quality of life. Maintaining independence. Preserving cognition. Minimising treatment burden. These are just some of the factors that frail and elderly people living with lung cancer will be weighing up when considering what matters most to them. 

“It makes sense to start with the individual’s goals and priorities and build a care plan from there,” says Vince. “Patient-focused care plans need to be built on an understanding of an individual’s lived reality, an openness to discuss personal wellbeing and a commitment to shared decision making from the outset.” 

Let’s take the burden of treatment as an example. “Flexible administration routes, such as subcutaneous formulations which are quick to administer, can help integrate treatment into daily routines," notes Vince. This is often particularly important for elderly or frail patients and their caregivers, who find the hospital visits for intravenous infusions physically, emotionally and logistically exhausting.6

Two hands holding together
What can be done to improve treatment options for frail and elderly lung cancer patients?

Knowledge is power.

“Generating robust evidence is essential for enabling informed treatment decisions,” Vince says. “This is why improving patient representation within clinical trials - including those who are elderly and frail - is so important and a focus of what we’re doing across our programmes at Roche. Addressing underrepresentation helps close the evidence gap for the very patients clinicians treat most often.”

What does the future hold for lung cancer treatment?

Vince’s take? “The opportunity to work with clinicians and the lung cancer community to support the treatment of every unique lung cancer patient – including the frail and elderly - is what drives us forward each day. Whether it’s building a stronger evidence base through our trials, innovating treatment options and solutions, or working with the community to think beyond traditional treatment protocols – I believe we can, and will, deliver tangible progress.”

Clinical and Community Perspectives on Identifying Frailty

Potrait of christian-schulz-prof-of-medicine

Nearly 1 in 2 patients with NSCLC present with an ECOG performance status of two or higher, which we would typically regard as reflecting a considerable degree of frailty.

Prof. Dr. med. Christian Schulz

Universitätsklinikum Regensburg

Potrait of Debra Montague

I think one of the biggest challenges for elderly patients being diagnosed with lung cancer is whether they're being objectively assessed on the frailty, and that's important to do so.

Debra Montague

President of Lung Cancer Europe

Potrait of christian-schulz-prof-of-medicine

Treatment decisions need to reflect more than just tumour biology; they must also consider organ function and the broader physical stresses our patients are experiencing.

Prof. Dr. med. Christian Schulz

Universitätsklinikum Regensburg

Potrait of  petros-christopoulos-prof-of-medicine

Frail patients in our daily practice cannot be managed in the same way as the fitter patients that typically predominate in registrational clinical trials. Their care must account for any comorbidities and the reduced physiological reserves, while also respecting individual preferences.

Prof. Dr. med. Petros Christopoulos

Thoraxklinik Heidelberg

Potrait of Upal Basu

My plea to any clinician who treats frail or elderly patients with lung cancer is not to rely on their own subjective assessment of the person's health status. It is highly recommended that they use an objective geriatic assessment tool or an objective frailty assessment tool to determine what the person's health status is before starting on the treatment plan

Upal Basu Roy

PhD, MPH, Executive Director of Research, Lungetivity Foundation

Potrait of  petros-christopoulos-prof-of-medicine

Chronological age tells how many years someone has lived, whereas biological age gives us insight into patients' functional reserve. This distinction underscores the importance of standardised frailty assessment for guiding treatment decisions in metastatic lung cancer. Comprehensive Geriatic Assessment, or CGA, is widely regarded as gold standard.

Prof. Dr. med. Petros Christopoulos

Thoraxklinik Heidelberg

Potrait of Mark Brooke

We know that there are vast numbers and types of treatments now available to lung cancer patients, but older and frail people might have a different and unique set of circumstances that they might need to consider - not the least of which is the tolerability of treatments. So it's really important to sit down and have an open and honest conversation with all patients, particularly those that are older and more frail, about how they might work and understand their treatment

Mark Brooke

CEO of Lung Foundation Australia

References:

  1. Surveillance, epidemiology, and end results program (SEER). 2024. Cancer stat facts: lung and bronchus cancer. National Cancer Institute. https://seer.cancer.gov/statfacts/html/lungb.html

  2. Camerini A, et al. Selection criteria and treatment outcome for advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients unfit for platinum-based first-line therapy: results of the MOON-OSS observational trial. Cancer. 2022;14:1-10.

  3. Mojsak D, et al. Immunotherapy in patients with non-small cell lung cancer with ECOG PS 2. Contemp Oncol (Pozn) 2021;25 (1):53–56.

  4. Hernandez-Aguiar Y, et al. Frailty and oncology: an increasingly common combination. Cancer Medicine. 2025;15:1-9.

  5. Young R. P., et al. COPD prevalence is increased in lung cancer, independent of age, sex and smoking history. Eur Respir J 2009;34: 380–386.

  6. Rosenberg T, et al. Home-based daratumumab in patients with multiple pyeloma. Eur J Haematol. 2025 Jul;115(1):72-81.

Discover more

Lung cancer

Solutions

Lung cancer is a complex disease, but ongoing research, advanced clinical trials and investigational medicines in the pipeline will continue to uncover answers that save and improve lives.

More stories

See all stories